Strategist answers · Editors / agencies serving channels · 500K to 2M
I freelance edit long videos and Shorts for a growing channel around 1.9M subs; how do I get useful automated rough cuts when silence trimming keeps deleting the pauses before our reveals?
For 1.5M-2M Editors / agencies serving channels channels; freelance editor; long-form + Shorts; growing.
82% of this answer is quoted word for word from 5 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
For a freelance editor serving a growing 1.9M subscriber channel, the rough-cut question starts with a closer look at the automation:
“It scans your video, understands the different takes. For example, here take one, take two, take three, chooses the best, and then uh brings it all together. So, for example, this video was initially all the gray area was cut out, all silences, all repetitions, and then cuts it into a 1 minute 7 video. So, something that took hours now just takes a couple minutes.”
For the pauses before reveals in both long videos and Shorts, George Blackman supplies a storytelling angle to consider alongside that automated pass:
“And honestly, this is the step that trips YouTubers up the most when writing their scripts. Tension, or the bit between your setups and your payoffs, can feel like a bit of a living nightmare because it's just the longest bit, right? There's so many different ways you could go and it feels hard to systematize this.”
For the freelance editing workload across both formats, Ed Lawrence offers two practical examples to put alongside that discussion of setups and payoffs:
“It took 40 minutes of out-of-order footage, reordered it correctly, cut it up, and added basic text and graphics without making a mistake at a speed that is not possible for a human to do. I was a pro editor for five years, I am very fast at editing, but that would have taken me about an hour and it would have been a really boring, annoying job I would have hated.”
“Now, I wanted to add some jump cuts into my edit. So a jump cut is where people jump in and out of the footage. But not too fast or not in the middle of a word cause it's annoying. See how annoying that is? Like never do this cause people absolutely hate it. I mean, it gives them a headache. So don't do it. You promise me you won't do it?”
Dabi and Mario Joos bring different emphases to the broader AI discussion behind this rough-cut problem for a freelance editor:
“For me, those two things in the YouTube space are storytelling and using AI agents. And then having two spiky things together can lead to really interesting combinations (e.g. I’m able to code my own agentic video editor that actually follows YouTube retention principles — to be released soon).”
“The biggest issue is that everyone has a different understanding of what makes for AI slop. Some people call anything created with AI "AI slop." Other people focus on the quality differences between AI- and human-generated content. There's just not one clear, defined definition of what makes something AI slop. AI is an absolutely fantastic tool that could be used to speed up your creative processes, however, it is often used to replace the entire creative process.”
Join Coeditor's invite-only beta waitlist for rough cuts planned against 90 storytelling rules. Read the reasons for its keeps and cuts, then overrule decisions that weaken your reveal. Coeditor
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.