Strategist answers · Editors / agencies serving channels · 50K to 500K
My agency's Shorts client reached 180K subs with the same reveal format, but views now drop each week; how do I refresh the storytelling without losing what regular viewers recognise?
For 100K-200K Editors / agencies serving channels channels; editing agency; Shorts-first; declining.
81% of this answer is quoted word for word from 6 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
For the agency's 180K-subscriber Shorts client, Leroy ter Braak offers a starting point for examining the weekly decline:
“There can be many things, hard to capture in one comment. But main issues I see: 1. Format fatigue 2. Supply/demand shifts 3. Topic fatigue All need different approaches to “fix”. But sometimes, a downtrend is a downtrend. Just gotta keep uploading great videos and things will start to look up over time as long as you keep a close eye on how videos behave”
1of10 favours continuity; Dabi, discussing top creators, emphasises risk. These different priorities speak to the agency's concern about an established format:
“3/ Double down on Format When a video wins, don't just make a "Part 2." Apply the same visual and structural format to a new subject. If a storytelling guide works, use that same exact structure for a "Hooks" guide. It's easier to scale a winning format than a winning topic.”
“Novel concepts for top 0.01% YouTubers to focus on: 1. Risk. - YouTube channels can go stale with riskless content - Bravery/boldness should be considered as a new variable to directly optimise for”
For the client's reveal storytelling, Daniel Faraday adds a broader principle and a tentative, specific observation:
“Because every video that does well is a balance between two things. Too familiar and there's no reason to click because the viewer has already seen it before. But too new and there's no reason to click either. The viewer doesn't know that they want it yet.”
“in a 5.6m view home makeover, the 20 seconds before the reveal had music only. frank lloyd wright built low, dark halls that opened into tall, bright rooms. the small hall made the room feel bigger. reveals might work the same way.”
For the editing agency's work on the next Shorts scripts, George Blackman offers a more detailed storytelling approach:
“Now, honestly, I get why it feels that way, but what I'm going to do now is show you the simple three-step formula I use to write tension that allows you to teach the viewer new information continuously without giving away that payoff until the end.”
“And then after the tension phase, we have our payoff to catch any viewers up who might not have quite followed the explanation. So, that's tension. Show them their current behavior, teach them why that behavior doesn't work, and gradually reveal what they should do instead.”
For an agency weighing audience feedback during this declining run of Shorts, Ed Lawrence adds a caveat:
“Everyone has different tastes, things are subjective, so just keep that in mind. Now if you get loads of comments saying the same thing, there's probably a sign, but be careful because if you make a change based on them only, you might actually wreck the thing your viewers loved in the first place.”
Work through Dabi's YouTube Storytelling: Far Beyond Retention to rethink structure and payoff for your next reveal. Its 38 lessons cover structuring, scripting and editing for retention and satisfaction. Storytelling course
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.