Strategist answers · AI niche · 500K to 2M
My AI channel is stuck around 1.2M subs, and our eight-person team's Shorts viewers leave long videos almost immediately; how do I write an opening that makes the longer experiment worth their time?
For 1M-1.5M AI niche channels; full team (6+); long-form + Shorts; stalled.
85% of this answer is quoted word for word from 5 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
For an AI channel at 1.2M subs, George Blackman's scripting advice focuses on the moments straight after the hook:
“Have you ever written a hook for a YouTube video and thought that the hard part was over? Well, think again because there is a major mistake that even the most experienced YouTubers make right after the hook and it causes retention to go like this in a way that most videos can never recover from. But after writing and reviewing hundreds of YouTube scripts for channels of all different sizes, I've discovered a simple fix for this problem that's going to ensure your videos never run into this problem.”
“Long list videos, technical tutorials, anything where segments three, four, and five get progressively harder to follow, these are the videos where segment one needs to give the viewer a quick win before the difficulty ramps up. And so, the E of our DES acronym is quite simply easy to implement. But what if I told you that some of your viewers are destined to never finish your videos from the moment they first click unless you say something very particular after your hook.”
Mario Joos sees the Shorts audience as separate, while others frame the issue as overlap:
“YouTube Shorts aren't a great strategy for growing a long-form audience if that's what you meant! However, it's great for growing a short-form audience. They're seperate”
“Um but what people will do is they don't really take the time to think about the different topics they're covering uh video to video and how different those audiences can sometimes be. The rule of thumb I like to go by is 80% audience overlap. So what I mean by that is across everything on a channel um I I always want to as I always want to make sure that at least 80% of the audience would click on any combination of those videos.”
“A full pivot wouldn’t be my preferred method to revive an old channel, mainly because if there is zero audience overlap, initial signs to the algorithm will be “bad”.”
For a stalled channel with an eight-person team, Mario Joos also looks beyond the opening to the format itself:
“This sound simple, but first a format that you can own and dominate in. Many people around that 1-2 mil range are just stuck in formats that all their competitors are doing and they're not focused on pushing to innovate”
Before going longer, Dabi adds a caveat and Leroy ter Braak points to how videos connect:
“but I’m talking about the *gradient* here, which is diminishing, and therefore has potential knock-on consequences to what creators do/should do.”
“If you want to push your overall earnings up, ensure your videos feed into each other well. Pushing up channel session/watch time can be a great tool.”
Rework your next long-form opening with YouTube Storytelling: Far Beyond Retention. It covers the clickbait trap, where a good click leads into a boring video, alongside structure and scripting. Storytelling course
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.