Strategist answers · B2B / SaaS · 500K to 2M
I've stalled around 1.7M subs making B2B SaaS Shorts with a freelance editor; why do my quick software tips still get views while barely anyone subscribes or comes back for the next upload?
For 1.5M-2M B2B / SaaS channels; solo + freelance editor; Shorts-first; stalled.
85% of this answer is quoted word for word from 7 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
At 1.7M subs on a Shorts-first B2B SaaS channel, the headline number can hide what is actually happening. Start with what a subscriber is:
“Subscribers ≠ audience All a subscriber really is, is someone who clicked a button one time. It doesn't mean they'll watch your next video. So even though there's a lot of ego and prestige that comes with a big subscriber count”
“GaryVee has 4.89M YouTube subscribers. A typical video gets 80K views, or 1.6% of his subscribers. That was the lowest share among the 18 big operator channels I checked. For comparison, Mark Tilbury has 9.2M subscribers and gets 3M views on a typical video. Subscribers show who signed up. Views show who is still watching.”
Several strategists point to the returning viewer base as the missing piece:
“9. a new upload ≠ a fresh start • low returning-viewer rate means every video starts from zero • channels that "suddenly blow up" spent years making every upload start ahead”
“The reason most YouTube advice destroys beginner channels is simple: It assumes you already have what beginners don't. A returning viewer base. Without that, every metric you're told to optimize is just noise dressed up as strategy.”
For a narrower B2B SaaS audience, Paddy Galloway and Mario Joos weigh repeat viewers differently:
“Simple rationale: if the niche is small, putting more time in has diminishing marginal returns. There’s not an infinite amount of viewers so I’d rather hit that small group regularly than chase a higher % of TAM when the TAM is small.”
“Note that there’s often overestimation of how many viewers watch every video on your channel. So even returning viewers may be alienated when they miss a single video. In general, make your videos and your content appeal to both new and returning viewers and refrain from expecting that viewers have an understanding from other videos.”
Not everyone thinks returning viewers are the fix. Ed Lawrence and Mario Joos push attention elsewhere:
“I'm explaining why obsessing over increasing monthly return YouTube viewers isn't always helpful. And here's how I did it. I compared your channel to a bucket with a hole in it. The hole represents viewers dropping off and not coming back. But I said, if you just keep topping up with new people, the right people, it doesn't matter. the bucket stays full and that's how you can still build a business.”
“Ignore the subs, revive in terms of views. In terms of format, they're two different audience, pick whichever type of content you enjoy making the most”
Dabi pushes back on dismissing subscribers altogether:
“A common “contrarian” piece of knowledge amongst YouTubers is the following statement: > subscribers are a vanity metric But actually, I’d like to argue the following instead. Subscribers are, in fact, a genius piece of incentive design. You see, every YouTuber knows that individual videos fluctuate in their views.”
Dabi's YouTube Storytelling: Far Beyond Retention gives you a system for structuring, scripting and editing around retention and satisfaction. Bring your next software tip to its 38 lessons with that returning-viewer problem in mind. Storytelling course
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.