Strategist answers · Coaches / consultants · 500K to 2M
At around 1.7M subs on my coaching channel, my freelancer cuts advice Shorts that get views, but hardly anyone subscribes or returns for the full lessons; what am I missing between quick answers and longer stories?
For 1.5M-2M Coaches / consultants channels; solo + freelance editor; long-form + Shorts; growing.
82% of this answer is quoted word for word from 7 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
At 1.7M subscribers with Shorts pulling views, it helps to ask whether those viewers were ever a long-form audience.
“YouTube Shorts aren't a great strategy for growing a long-form audience if that's what you meant! However, it's great for growing a short-form audience. They're seperate”
“Long form has 10x increase in views per video, I don’t really count shorts and longs together when looking at growth.”
The overlap problem can be subtle, even within one coach's brand.
“Because let's let's say you have a golf channel, you're teaching people how to get better at golf. If you go off and you make a video about how to get better at, you know, playing baseball, you know, that's a more obvious example, the golf people they're probably not going to click on it. But this even shows up in very subtle ways that you wouldn't really expect.”
“It is the same face, name, and business advice from the same coaching rooms. But YouTube does not move an audience to a new channel just because the name is on it.”
When a freelance editor cuts standalone advice, where the answer lands matters; George Blackman and Mario Joos both flag the same habit.
“Now, most creators instinctively give the payoff at the start of a segment, saying something that sounds quite reasonable, like this. The single best way to save money without thinking about it is to automate a transfer the day after payday. But, can you see the problem there? That is a payoff. That's the reveal. That's the thing that I, as the viewer, am supposed to be curious about. So, starting a segment with something like that destroys the viewer's curiosity.”
“This is more for educational creators, but giving too much generic advice up front, while keeping the exciting information for when most people already left the video”
Ed Lawrence adds a coaching-specific angle on what moves a viewer from watching to signing up:
“The feedback you give makes your expertise impossible to miss. And the people watching get to experience your coaching. And when people experience what its like to work with you... they sign up faster.”
On whether subscriber growth should be the goal at all, Ed Lawrence and Dabi weigh it differently.
“as a business you're going to pick up subscribers and a lot of them are going to start with good intentions where they really want to learn about your topic but a lot of them will quit and those quitters will also forget to unsubscribe so lesson 24 is that subscriber accounts are often just graveyards focus on views per video rather than growing your sub count”
“Subscribers are the emotional stock of a YouTube channel as a system. Even if we know subscribers aren’t views per se, it’s a number we can’t help but want to keep push up and up.”
Dabi's YouTube Storytelling: Far Beyond Retention teaches a system for structuring, scripting and editing for retention and satisfaction. Bring your next full lesson and work on the story beyond its opening answer. Storytelling course
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.