My consulting channel is stuck around 17K subs, and our three-person team's weekly videos sound like service pitches; how do I build a useful story without making every example a sales argument?
For 10K-20K Coaches / consultants channels; small team (2-5); long-form only; stalled.
84% of this answer is quoted word for word from 7 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source.
For a three-person consulting team whose weekly videos sound like service pitches, Daniel Faraday and George Blackman start with what the viewer gets from each story.
“a personal story does one of three things to a viewer: 1. the viewer learns from it 2. the viewer envies it 3. the viewer admires it each one is a different video. learn: "the mistake that cost me my first business" the viewer wants the lesson. the story carries the steps.”
“But on the other hand, if your viewer gets a tangible result in the first 90 seconds, something they can immediately go and apply, well, that's a signal that this video is worth their time, even if it gets more complex later on. To go back to the personal finance example, maybe that's showing them how to open a brokerage account in under 5 minutes or something like that. That signal buys you a little more of their patience for the more complicated stuff that comes later.”
George Blackman's warning about subject matter experts applies to consultants, and Mario Joos adds a structural point for long-form stories.
“I was consulting with a 750,000 subscriber channel just recently who was struggling with exactly this. Now, this channel, like you, is a subject matter expert in their topic, but as a result, they have a habit of going super deep into a bunch of rabbit holes that arguably, their viewers might not even care about. And this is a real risk for you, too.”
“If you're following a more traditional story arc and you think in three acts, then keep your first act short. The first act in storytelling is used for world building and learning more about the characters. However, this does tend to be slower in the delivery of content viewers care about, which causes a mismatch in the desired pacing and the pacing that we are having in our story.”
Daniel Faraday and Dabi both pull the focus back to the real viewer rather than the offer.
“Your target viewer is not a person. It's a repeated psychological moment. Perhaps it's when someone opens their phone at the gym to procrastinate. Perhaps it's the moment that a viewer opens their phone at 1:00 a.m. because their channel isn't growing and they can't sleep. Maybe they open YouTube on their TV because they have 2 hours to kill on a Sunday.”
“I do this partly to try to stay grounded in the real world, especially when it’s easy for YouTube strategy to look too much like a numbers and systems optimisation game. Every view is a real person.”
For a channel stalled near 17K subs, Leroy ter Braak looks for signals in what has already worked.
“Look at your channel and your competitors. Find the videos that outperformed everything else. Those are signals. Most creators see them and don't value them enough. B - Build Start making videos that align with those signals. But don't just copy.”
Two final angles on the business side: Ed Lawrence offers a caution, and Paddy Galloway contrasts how audiences feel about creators.
“So they start thinking, I need to do this too. So instead of focusing on the business, they spent three days every week doing hooks, planning content, filming videos, looking at analytics. And, ironically, the more attention they gave to growing the personal brand, the worse their business started performing.”
“With YouTubers if you buy their merch and watch their mid-roll ads, you sometimes feel like you're just lining their pockets, which is perfectly fine. But with Jimmy, you feel like you're helping him change YouTube and make other people's lives better. Standing for something attracts other people to get behind you.”
Dabi's YouTube Storytelling: Far Beyond Retention gives you a system for structuring, scripting and editing. Apply it to your next client example so the video has a story beyond the pitch. Storytelling course