Strategist answers · Comedy / sketch · 50K to 500K
I've stalled around 125K subs making comedy Shorts alone; my recurring flatmate gag used to carry every upload, but now viewers guess the ending, so how do I evolve it?
For 100K-200K Comedy / sketch channels; solo; Shorts-first; stalled.
82% of this answer is quoted word for word from 6 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
For a solo comedy Shorts creator stalled at 125K subscribers, Leroy ter Braak offers several possible diagnoses:
“There can be many things, hard to capture in one comment. But main issues I see: 1. Format fatigue 2. Supply/demand shifts 3. Topic fatigue All need different approaches to “fix”. But sometimes, a downtrend is a downtrend. Just gotta keep uploading great videos and things will start to look up over time as long as you keep a close eye on how videos behave”
For what comes after the familiar flatmate setup, 1of10 and Daniel Faraday offer different angles:
“People watch YouTube like they watch TV. If they liked one episode, they want another one. And the best way to give that to them is by reusing the format: - same structure - same packaging style - just swap the topic Why it works: Every video in the same format pulls in the same viewers. That gives YouTube a clear signal about who to show your next video to. Change formats every upload and you reset that signal every time.”
“The interesting thing is that originality isn't necessarily what makes an idea exciting. It's the *contrast* between something the viewer already wants, and something they've never seen before. You don't need to make EVERYTHING new. You need to make ONE thing new enough to create curiosity, while keeping the rest familiar enough to matter.”
For the recurring flatmate joke itself, Mario Joos offers a different angle from the discussion of repeating formats:
“But to the viewers, especially if they didn’t find it funny the first time or didn’t instantly connect with the joke, they will struggle to connect with the content, especially once we start doubling down on the joke. Don’t force humor through repetition, force it through variation of comedy, and you’ll be more likely to keep people engaged for longer.”
For regular viewers of the flatmate gag and newcomers encountering a Short, Ed Lawrence weighs both sides of familiarity:
“I I always think of YouTube as the playground, and there's the cool kids standing in the center chain and you're on the outside. And what you wanna do is you wanna be welcoming to the cold viewers. You don't want them to make them feel like they're not part of the gang. So if you go too deep on a tangent, it can be counterproductive.”
“It's not necessarily about new. If you keep writing for the new, you can often start playing it too safe, and it gets a bit boring.”
Alongside those perspectives, Dabi offers another consideration for a solo creator whose established comedy premise has become predictable:
“Novel concepts for top 0.01% YouTubers to focus on: 1. Risk. - YouTube channels can go stale with riskless content - Bravery/boldness should be considered as a new variable to directly optimise for”
Rebuild the next flatmate sketch around structure and payoff with YouTube Storytelling: Far Beyond Retention. Its system connects scripting and editing with retention and satisfaction. Storytelling course
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.