New: YouTube Storytelling: Beyond Retention - Course Now Available

Strategist answers · Commentary / reaction · 500K to 2M

My commentary channel has around 1.7M subs and falling views; how do I get a useful automated rough cut when everything my three-person team tries chops out the pauses that make reactions funny?

For 1.5M-2M Commentary / reaction channels; small team (2-5); long-form only; declining.

86% of this answer is quoted word for word from 5 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .

Paddy Galloway's breakdowns of other creators' edits are a useful starting point on why pauses earn their place.

“in these opening 10 seconds there were 11 different sound changes the discord pinging almost forces you to stay engaged the explosion sound effects and music add variety and the awkward pauses emphasizes the humor it's very hard to feel bored with so much happening a lot of creators focus all their attention on the visual edits and not enough on the sound”
Paddy Galloway (@PaddyG96), "How Beluga Gained 4 Million Subscribers in 3 Months (Genius Strategy)" at 6:09; transcribed from auto-captions
“pause or a joke for comedic relief. This keeps the viewers on their toes and it stops the video feeling too linear. And then there's the golden moment, the glass bridge scene. In my opinion, this is the best five minutes I have ever seen on YouTube. It starts slow and then as the time ticks by the tension builds.”
Paddy Galloway (@PaddyG96), "How MrBeast's Squid Game Broke YouTube (Genius Strategy)"; transcribed from a machine transcript

Mario Joos goes further, suggesting some moments call for less editing, not more:

“While those visuals can improve pacing and make a video feel more exciting, some niches work better with a raw, natural tone. Podcasts, for example, usually benefit from minimal editing; not none, but less. The same applies to certain story-driven or process-focused videos. Sometimes it even helps to dial back the editing in certain moments, like scenes with suspense or tension, where the story itself should carry the emotion. The main idea is to match your editing style to your audience and content.”
Mario Joos (@MarioJoos), X post, 2025-11-15

On automation itself, Ed Lawrence's tests show its speed and its limits, while Mario Joos adds a caveat about its role:

“It took 40 minutes of out-of-order footage, reordered it correctly, cut it up, and added basic text and graphics without making a mistake at a speed that is not possible for a human to do. I was a pro editor for five years, I am very fast at editing, but that would have taken me about an hour and it would have been a really boring, annoying job I would have hated.”
Ed Lawrence (Film Booth) (@Ed_FilmBooth), "ChatGPT Astra Just Changed YouTube Forever"; transcribed from a machine transcript
“But not too fast or not in the middle of a word cause it's annoying. See how annoying that is? Like never do this cause people absolutely hate it. I mean, it gives them a headache. So don't do it. You promise me you won't do it? Okay, cool. So we're just asked it to add them in sparingly when it believed it made sense to add a jump cut. And look, it kind of did it.”
Ed Lawrence (Film Booth) (@Ed_FilmBooth), "ChatGPT Astra Just Changed YouTube Forever"; transcribed from a machine transcript
“AI is an absolutely fantastic tool that could be used to speed up your creative processes, however, it is often used to replace the entire creative process.”
Mario Joos (@MarioJoos), X post, 2026-11-03

With views falling at 1.7M subs, Dabi and Daniel Faraday offer two cautions worth weighing before overhauling the workflow:

“1. If you have a good format or type of video that’s important for creating views, not a good idea to abandon it entirely unless you’ve got a really good reason to.”
Dabi (@dabidoYT), X post, 2026-09-06
“Posting more kept the channel busy. It didn’t make each video get more views. If views per video are falling, doubling the posting rate probably won’t fix the problem.”
Daniel Faraday (@FaradayYouTube), X post, 2026-10-21

Join Coeditor's invite-only beta waitlist for rough cuts planned against 90 storytelling rules. You can read the reason for each keep or cut and overrule choices that spoil your timing. Coeditor

Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.