Strategist answers · Commentary / reaction · 500K to 2M
With around 1.8M subs on my reaction channel, how do I stop long videos becoming six people's favourite tangents stitched together when our Shorts land but the main uploads keep losing viewers?
For 1.5M-2M Commentary / reaction channels; full team (6+); long-form + Shorts; declining.
82% of this answer is quoted word for word from 8 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
When Shorts are landing at 1.8M subs, the long-form numbers need to be read separately.
“Long form has 10x increase in views per video, I don’t really count shorts and longs together when looking at growth.”
“4. Understand that a retention curve is the total duration divided by 100 points. So for example, a 100 minute long video means each point is a full minute! (in 2026) That is important for retention analyses.”
For a team of six or more pitching favourite tangents, three strategists come at structure from different angles:
“So, one of the things that I've kind of started doing recently which has which has been really helpful is just stripping the formats back to kind of kind of like the core principles of what this format is trying to say.”
“And now, the curiosity is no longer what the answer is, it's why their current understanding of that answer is incomplete. Now, the payoffs throughout the rest of the video become jigsaw pieces for that puzzle instead.”
“most creators think the promise has to be the new part of a video. it rarely does. keep the promise as familiar as you can. put the surprise somewhere else.”
For commentary and reaction content specifically, Mario Joos puts the weight somewhere many reaction teams might not expect:
“However, most viewers don't come here to connect to the reactions of the main creator. They come here to experience the same story through your lens, meaning that they need to be impressed and they need to feel the emotions given by what is happening in the video. If you're impressed by something, that is fine to show your impressed reaction, but make sure that most of the focus goes towards the objective value of the video, not the subjective emotional contribution of the creator.”
Ed Lawrence and Leroy ter Braak both judge a long upload partly by what viewers do after it ends:
“You check your comments to see if you hit your comment goals and if you did enough to inspire an emotional reaction from your audience and then you need to establish if you manage to get people to watch another video after because we don't want one video to get watched ever. We want people to watch 10 in a row because that's what makes channels fly.”
“If you want to push your overall earnings up, ensure your videos feed into each other well. Pushing up channel session/watch time can be a great tool.”
For a channel in decline, Daniel Faraday offers one data point on long-form output:
“Charlie Morgan posted about a third as many long-form videos in 2024. A typical video got about 14 times as many views. 2022: 150 videos, 4.2K typical views 2024: 54 videos, 59K typical views His total long-form views were higher too. His breakout year came with fewer posts.”
Give your team a shared structure for the next main upload with Dabi's YouTube Storytelling: Far Beyond Retention. Its lessons cover scripting, editing and the mid-video loss of direction. Storytelling course
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.