Strategist answers · Commentary / reaction · under 50K
My commentary channel is stuck around 14K subs, and my freelance editor keeps sending back repeated points for me to resolve; how do I tighten long talking-head takes without endless timestamp notes?
For 10K-20K Commentary / reaction channels; solo + freelance editor; long-form only; stalled.
88% of this answer is quoted word for word from 6 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
For a stalled commentary channel around 14K, two strategists start with what gets said on camera:
“So they ramble, bury their point, and the viewer checks out. The fix is to write your point in one sentence before you film anything. Then make sure everything in the video explains that sentence, and cut anything that doesn't.”
“While repetition is often good in an educational setting, it tends to harm retention on YouTube because it lowers the overall pacing of a video. Retention is very driven by progression, and repetition tends to stall progression. Therefore, it’s often recommended to reduce repetition. When you’re explaining something, say things once. Don’t restate them with an analogy or say something in a different way, because that is also seen as a type of repetition. This is what we often refer to as implied repetition.”
George Blackman moves the fix earlier, into the script, and says where notes for a freelance editor belong:
“the headline for this part is plot your payoffs first and put them at the end of each segment because forcing yourself to map out the punchy, exciting moments up front gives you a bird's-eye view of the script skeleton. It's way easier to check the overall flow of A to B to C and whether you've actually got enough interesting payoffs in the first place.”
“Column three is visuals. It's notes for your editor or for you if you are your editor. Describe your B-roll choices or editing suggestions or leave links to assets, whatever it might be your editor will need to do their thing.”
Paddy Galloway adds a caveat on pace for long talking-head takes:
“if i'm talking to this camera and you're not cutting it for too long that's boring you'll lose retention but if i talk and you cut to that angle i'm talking and cut back and you know it helps it but people often make the mistake of thinking that this is just about having lots of cuts and talking really fast there's a lot more to it than that”
“Here's the key though, it's almost impossible to keep this pace up for the whole video, and if he did, it would feel too fast and probably get quite repetitive. So in the edit, MrBeast strategically places breather moments within the action. For example, sections like these between games, where we get the player's reactions. What ends up happening throughout the video is an alternation between fast and slow.”
On the back-and-forth with a freelance editor, Daniel Faraday, Ed Lawrence and Dabi each come at it from a different angle:
“swap the junior editor for a senior one. a senior editor has their own judgment, so they don't need your notes. the new problem is that you now have a group of freelancers to keep in sync.”
“So really the simplest thing that we did to help him was just have a long list of lessons he's learned, mistakes he's made around creating videos so that he doesn't do that the next time.”
“But, longer videos are (obviously) more resource intensive to make, for the majority of creators. Risking it all on one video creates a greater risk of it flops. It’s also cognitively more demanding, and editors can burn out.”
Join Coeditor's invite-only beta waitlist to try rough cuts with readable reasons for every keep and cut. You can overrule decisions before handing off your next commentary edit. Coeditor
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.