Strategist answers · Documentary / video essay · under 50K
At 18K subs, my documentary channel is growing, but researching breakout topics eats my only editing day; how do I compare smaller channels' outliers while making essays and Shorts alone?
For 10K-20K Documentary / video essay channels; solo; long-form + Shorts; growing.
83% of this answer is quoted word for word from 6 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
For a growing documentary channel at 18K subscribers, these are two starting points for comparing smaller peers:
“how to read an outlier score by channel size (in 4 steps): 1) small channel, high outlier: strongest signal there is. execution rarely separates videos at that size, so the positioning is what's resonating. 2) large channel, moderate outlier: muddy. momentum might be doing it.”
“Outlier niche research settings: > Outlier Score: 2x+ > Views: 100K+ > Subscribers: max 25K (smaller channels only) > Publication date: Last month You can just play around with these settings to find interesting niches 👀”
For the next essay, 1of10 and Daniel Faraday differ over how much reassurance other channels can provide:
“But here's the key: outlier validation So don't just find 1 outlier on a topic Find 3+ videos on the same concept that all became outliers (recently) Because it worked for 3 channels, it'll probably work for you too”
“And it's SO tempting to hide behind the pseudo-science. It's stupidly easy to make excuses in this industry. To substitute patterns from other channels and call it analysis. Which means optimising for an audience that doesn't actually exist on your channel. Avoiding the tension, pressure, and awkwardness that's naturally a symptom of genuine creativity.”
With research consuming a solo creator’s only editing day, Leroy ter Braak and Ed Lawrence offer different emphases:
“I spend at LEAST 120 minutes per week on idea research. It's the highest-ROI thing for YouTubers. Here's the exact process (steal it): First, I pick 10-20 channels adjacent to our niche. Mix of sizes: some bigger, some smaller, some at the same level.”
“Or should I just go for something more obvious and put that on the back burner for another time? But a word of warning, this doesn't mean make what you want. You still need to research, research, research and find the right videos to make and understand your audience but when you have that down, trusting your instincts could be your secret source.”
For producing essays and Shorts alone, Paddy Galloway offers two perspectives on the workload and audience:
“If long term you want a shorts audience, just post shorts. If long term you want a long form audience, post long forms now. The transition from shorts to long form doesn’t exist in a meaningful way. Truly I would do both, try master both skills. Go for it!”
“Dedicated shorts for most part. But depends on goal, it’s a lot more work and if we don’t really care about growing a short form audience, clips are way to go.”
When comparing the resulting documentaries as the channel grows, Dabi adds a timing consideration:
“New videos are slower to gain views when they have longer video durations. So sometimes you just have to be more patient with them. Of course, it’s amazing if you can get views quickly.”
CreatorSide YouTube Scraper exports a channel's complete video metadata as a CSV. Bring those exports into your spreadsheet to compare potential outliers before committing your next editing day. YouTube Scraper
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.