Strategist answers · Educational / explainers · 500K to 2M
We're stuck around 1.9M subs on my explainer channel, with Shorts still moving but long videos flat. How can our three-person team tell whether clicks, watch time or viewer satisfaction needs attention first?
For 1.5M-2M Educational / explainers channels; small team (2-5); long-form + Shorts; stalled.
83% of this answer is quoted word for word from 7 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
With Shorts still moving and long videos flat at 1.9M, the first question is whether Shorts momentum should be expected to lift long-form at all.
“The bad news is that when you look at the data, you usually don’t see more than about 1% converting from short form to long form. And that still requires your long form to stand on its own. People watch shorts for a specific need. People watch long form for a different need. Sometimes there’s overlap, but not always. So I would treat them differently and not expect one to meaningfully convert into the other. Grow each with its own strategy.”
On clicks, these strategists warn against reading CTR on its own, though they frame the problem differently.
“If your CTR stays insanely high, it usually means YouTube never moved you to Phase 2 You got shown to people who already love you, then the algorithm stop giving it impressions That's why a 'great' thumbnail can still flop”
“CTR in isolation is a pretty useless metric. Focus on impressions. If you aren’t getting them it means YouTube just doesn’t know who to put it in front of. That’s where the demand/supply thing comes in effects again. Sometimes you just need to be patient, sometimes it’s an idea issue”
On watch time, Paddy Galloway and Dabi weigh it from different angles.
“View counts and retention curves are the two data points worth analyzing. Everything else is secondary. 5. If someone always talks about CTR and AVD (without context) assume they don’t really understand youtube.”
“It’s also just generally better for you the more time someone spends watching your content. That sounds obvious when said out loud, but creators often don’t think of “time spent with the creator” as a concept in itself for some reason. They think about watch time getting views, sure. But the watch time itself is valuable.”
Viewer satisfaction sits alongside both, as Daniel Faraday and Mario Joos describe.
“Increase production-quality to make your content more clickable, watchable, for a longer duration of time, with viewer satisfaction. This involves INVESTING in your team, training and educating your team - and also HEAVY focus in strategy. For most MAJOR niches on YouTube - this method is only an option if you have a very large budget to play with.”
“Audience satisfaction is central, but it depends on content produced through creative work. When the range of creative ideas becomes filtered, what I refer to as filtered creativity, long-term audience satisfaction is undermined.”
For a stalled explainer channel with a small team, another angle is to look at what has already worked on the channel.
“whenever I start with a client, the best like way to win and especially the best way to win early is to double down on things that have performed well on the channel so far. So that can basically mean doubling down on the interest topics or the subjects of the video or it can also be doubling down on like the format of the video.”
Before changing another thumbnail or script, read The YouTube Algorithm: Explained. It explains CTR, AVD and satisfaction signals to help you diagnose inconsistent views. Algorithm guide
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.