New: YouTube Storytelling: Beyond Retention - Course Now Available

Strategist answers · Entertainment · 500K to 2M

Why do my 25-minute entertainment reaction videos feel like disconnected tangents at 1.8M subs, even after my freelance editor tightens them, and what should I change before filming as views slide?

For 1.5M-2M Entertainment channels; solo + freelance editor; long-form only; declining.

85% of this answer is quoted word for word from 6 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .

Mario Joos, critiquing another creator's video, describes the disconnected feeling a wandering 25-minute reaction can create:

“Then we start getting information about 2003, but it still doesn’t feel like we’re getting to the point. We have this interesting comparison between the cars, but the viewer never really gets a clear idea of the journey the video will take. There’s no clear consequence or direction. It just feels like a lot of information being thrown at the viewer without setting up the story we’re actually going to tell.”
Mario Joos (@MarioJoos), X post, 2026-03-08

Before filming, Daniel Faraday and George Blackman suggest different depths of preparation for a solo creator handing footage to an editor:

“how i would do an expert reaction video: react to your viewer's heroes doing your craft. like this: - a sales expert reacts to famous sales calls - a copywriter reviews a famous founder's emails put a few in one video: 1. script only the hook. 2. list the moments. 3. record.”
Daniel Faraday (@FaradayYouTube), X post, 2026-10-13
“In a nutshell, we added recognizable stakes to our setup. So, don't be tempted to start bulking out your script too soon. Payoffs first, then setups, and now you have a complete skeleton to cast your eye over”
George Blackman (@GeorgeBlackman_), "The YouTube Script System Nobody Told You About" at 5:38; transcribed from auto-captions

On where reaction commentary should focus, Mario Joos and the 1of10 Podcast take a similar line:

“Many times, creators spend too much time, both in their teasers as well as throughout the content, focusing too much on the emotional reactions of the creator to a certain event. However, most viewers don't come here to connect to the reactions of the main creator. They come here to experience the same story through your lens, meaning that they need to be impressed and they need to feel the emotions given by what is happening in the video.”
Mario Joos (@MarioJoos), X post, 2026-04-01
“But our thing was the star was the topic. It wasn't like, "Hey guys, you know, everybody on YouTube is excited." And I was like, >> "That's great, >> super good, but we want to do something where it's a bit less erratic. It's really like informative and entertaining.”
1of10 Podcast (speaker not identified in captions) (@1of10media), "Everything I Learned from 18B YouTube Views in 71 Minutes" at 53:41; transcribed from auto-captions

Editing style itself varies widely in entertainment, as Ed Lawrence's comparison of two channels shows:

“This video has 8 million views and the first 4 minutes have no editing other than just a straight cut of a poking hairhead out of a bathtub. That's it. Meanwhile on Preston's channel we have this. He makes sure that every single second has some kind of movement going on from the camera movement to transitions to jump cuts.”
Ed Lawrence (Film Booth) (@Ed_FilmBooth), "Editing Hacks YouTubers Use To Hook You"; transcribed from a machine transcript

As views slide at 1.8M subs, Ed Lawrence and Dabi offer two lenses for an honest review:

“And then you look at your attention and you ask yourself how good a job did I do of keeping them entertained? You check your comments to see if you hit your comment goals and if you did enough to inspire an emotional reaction from your audience and then you need to establish if you manage to get people to watch another video after because we don't want one video to get watched ever.”
Ed Lawrence (Film Booth) (@Ed_FilmBooth), "This Stops 95% of YouTube Channels Growing"; transcribed from a machine transcript
“More than ever, people are disconnected from reality, leading to sloppiness of thought. It’s because the complexity of reality is genuinely hard. No-one wants to feel like what they’re doing is wrong. So people opt in to confirmation bias and protection of ego, instead of truth.”
Dabi (@dabidoYT), X post, 2026-09-29

Bring your next reaction outline to YouTube Storytelling: Far Beyond Retention. Dabi's course covers structuring, scripting and editing, including videos that hook viewers but lack a satisfying middle. Storytelling course

Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.