Strategist answers · Faceless · 500K to 2M
Where do I start auditing 600 long videos on my faceless channel at around 1.9M subs when growth has stalled and my freelance editor needs me to choose what we repeat?
For 1.5M-2M Faceless channels; solo + freelance editor; long-form only; stalled.
84% of this answer is quoted word for word from 7 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
With 600 long videos and a freelance editor waiting on direction, the first question is whose evidence to trust.
“Then you copy their strategy and it doesn't work, because you only saw half the picture. The channels that actually grow stop copying what worked for someone else and start figuring out what works for them.”
“Um I think that one of the biggest issues that I keep seeing people run into is audience segmentation. And that's something that will even of course like like beginners they'll run into that issue, but even like much more advanced people”
For a long-form only faceless catalogue, retention is the next lens.
“To get more views on your long-form video, it's important to focus on retention. That's because YouTube considers how long people watch as a signal to decide how much viewers enjoyed the video.”
“4. Understand that a retention curve is the total duration divided by 100 points. So for example, a 100 minute long video means each point is a full minute! (in 2026) That is important for retention analyses.”
Packaging and the way videos connect across the back catalogue offer another angle.
“And he'd been posting for a number of years. I believe he'd been on YouTube for about 10 years. And, you know, one of the first things that I noticed with his channel is um, you know, is the packaging, right? to like the thumbnails and you can see on his previous thumbnails there were a there was a lot of text on the thumbnail”
“If you want to push your overall earnings up, ensure your videos feed into each other well. Pushing up channel session/watch time can be a great tool.”
Daniel Faraday and Dabi each add a caution before simply repeating what already worked.
“Everything gets optimized by people who have studied what works. And what works - predictably - is what has already worked. So, why is this a problem for the creators?”
“6. Demand, as an aggregate, is also probably increasing — but maybe not as much as the supply (for JUST ultra long form videos) is filling 7. This easing of supply-demand asymmetry means that it will be harder to get views on ultra long-form videos”
A stall at around 1.9M subs is not necessarily permanent, as Paddy Galloway describes.
“But one year ago, Ryan hit a major problem. His growth had completely dried up. In the months of November and December 2020, he was actually losing subscribers, and his videos were sometimes struggling to crack 500k. He looked like another victim of the infamous YouTube downward spiral, where you blow up, peak and start to fall off. But a year later, the complete opposite has happened.”
Paste your channel URL into CreatorSide YouTube Scraper to export its complete video metadata as a CSV. Bring that into a spreadsheet for your back-catalogue audit. YouTube Scraper
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.