Strategist answers · Faceless · under 50K
Running my faceless channel alone at 19K subs, I spend four evenings rough-cutting each long video before touching Shorts, and views are dropping; how do I get my editing week under control?
For 10K-20K Faceless channels; solo; long-form + Shorts; declining.
81% of this answer is quoted word for word from 5 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
On balancing long videos and Shorts at 19K subscribers, Paddy Galloway and Mario Joos differ in emphasis:
“Highly dependant on long term goal. Long form is always my focus, with a lot of clients focus is probably 80% long form 20% shorts.”
“So I would say, if you want to be a Shorts channel, make short-form content. If you want to be a long-form channel, make long-form content. Trying to mix the two could work, but it typically comes with some nuance.”
With four evenings going into rough cuts alone, Dabi speaks directly to that editing stage:
“Or, if you're a video editor, you can produce rough cuts faster so that you can focus more on the important stuff. You can cut the obviously bad stuff quickly, so that you can focus on the more fun parts of the edit.”
Ed Lawrence adds a quality caveat to that prospect of faster editing for a solo creator:
“But sometimes the cuts are a bit sloppy. It cuts you off at the start of a word rather than letting the whole word play out. And sometimes it leaves too big a gap. And the graphics, they're okay. The animation, it's okay, it's all just okay. Which in some niches I think is fine, but I think most people need good now. And it's not quite good yet.”
For the faceless channel's declining views, Mario Joos offers a further perspective on editing:
“I post a lot about retention, and pretty much all of those principles directly or indirectly apply to retention editing. Retention editing is simply editing with the goal of making people watch longer. That can include how you handle visuals, how you use music, pacing, structure, all of it.”
Alongside the editing workload and falling views, Leroy ter Braak supplies a broader frame:
“Four different creators. Four very different niches. All grew using my IDEAL framework. ➤ Obsess over the idea ➤ Back it with data ➤ Execute better than everyone else ➤ Analyse the end product ➤ Build for longevity My formula doesn’t change. Only the creator does!”
“Hard to say from a distance. A ton of factors can influence it. Topic selection, execution.. etc. A full pivot wouldn’t be my preferred method to revive an old channel, mainly because if there is zero audience overlap, initial signs to the algorithm will be “bad”.”
Put your next rough cut on the Coeditor invite-only Mac beta waitlist agenda. It plans cuts from transcript story nodes, with readable reasons for keeps and cuts you can overrule. Coeditor
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.