Strategist answers · Family-friendly (not made for kids) · under 50K
Our family-friendly vlog channel is stuck at 17K subs, and our three-person team keeps making weekly recaps with Shorts attached, so how do I give each vlog an actual beginning, middle and payoff?
For 10K-20K Family-friendly (not made for kids) channels; small team (2-5); long-form + Shorts; stalled.
86% of this answer is quoted word for word from 6 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
For a stalled family-friendly channel at 17K subscribers, Daniel Faraday and Mario Joos offer starting points for the next weekly vlog:
“8. make the title and thumbnail before you film. they're a promise to the viewer. once you know the promise, you know exactly what the video has to deliver. do it the other way round and you end up with a weak promise stuck on at the end.”
“A cold opening is where the story just starts, no context given A warm opening is where we state context (most YouTube videos) or if you're thinking film, Star Wars starts with a warm opening”
For the three-person team's middle section, 1of10 and Mario Joos offer two angles:
“Great videos are not random. They are structured stories. Think in sections or chapters: Educational videos → each tip becomes a section Story videos → stages in the journey Challenge videos → rounds in the competition Structure is the skeleton of your video. Without it, videos drift and lose momentum. With it, everything flows.”
“Next up, we're going through this entire story up until like 50 seconds from a tournament that just made you realize that you were pretty decent at something. But all of that just felt like I just spent so long watching a story that isn't even relevant. Like, it's just a discovery. You could have easily condensed this one, which then allows you to focus on the current story, which is the more important story.”
On payoff, George Blackman describes entertainment's usual pattern; Dabi adds a caveat for stories without an inherent challenge:
“In pretty much any movie ever, the biggest moment of drama happens at the end of act three, right? Yes, there might be a couple of biggish moments in acts one and two, but ultimately, the people die, fall in love, explode, take revenge, save the world, or rescue the cat right at the very end. The whole story exists to serve that final moment, and honestly, you see the same approach with entertainment content on YouTube as well.”
“This was challenging for a different reason: how can we tell a story where there is no inherent goal or challenge? Ultimately, for YouTube storytelling like this, I think philosophically you’re really trying to emulate travelling. People watch these videos to escape. The journey is the destination, so you kind of relish the right things in the right order emotionally, whilst not lingering too long since we still do care about retention of course.”
For the Shorts attached to those weekly recaps, Paddy Galloway adds a separate format consideration:
“If long term you want a shorts audience, just post shorts. If long term you want a long form audience, post long forms now. The transition from shorts to long form doesn’t exist in a meaningful way. Truly I would do both, try master both skills. Go for it!”
Give your next vlog a clearer structure with Dabi's YouTube Storytelling: Far Beyond Retention. The course covers structuring, scripting and editing around retention and satisfaction. Storytelling course
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.