My investing channel is growing near 350K subs, but tracking 40 competitors' upload dates and views for a monthly review with my freelance editor is unwieldy; how do I organise that research?
For 300K-500K Personal finance / investing channels; solo + freelance editor; long-form + Shorts; growing.
83% of this answer is quoted word for word from 7 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source.
At 350K subs with 40 competitors, a monthly review with a freelance editor works best as a repeatable cycle rather than informal browsing.
“A - Assess Look at your channel and your competitors. Find the videos that outperformed everything else. Those are signals. Most creators see them and don't value them enough. B - Build Start making videos that align with those signals. But don't just copy. Make every video a few percentage points better than the last. Better hooks, better stories, better packaging. C - Compound Once you have momentum, protect it. 3 out of 4 videos every month should build on what's working. Use the 4th to experiment.”
“You move on to the second link in the chain. If you wanna transform your channel in two months, then start researching and looking for patterns 30 minutes a day.”
For the competitor records themselves, these passages describe what is worth capturing for each channel:
“1. Create a list of all competitors and add them to a tracked channel folder 2. Filter to show only videos from the last 6 months, at least 2x outlier score”
“Look at your top competitors' average views. If their videos regularly pull hundreds of thousands of views, the demand is real. Rough rule of thumb: around 80% of that audience is realistically yours to reach too.”
“There's a few tools out there, but they're all kinda doing the same. Tracking daily views, graphing them, tracking title and thumbnail changes, adding them.”
For labelling what turns up in the review, Daniel Faraday offers a different lens:
“He talks about breaking down successful videos, not by the topic and not by the format, but by the specific thing that made them possible in the first place. The resource, the access, the ability that a competitor couldn't replicate even if they copied everything else perfectly. That idea is the foundation of something I call advantage tags.”
Not every number deserves equal weight. Dabi warns some metrics are hard to read, and Daniel Faraday points back to the channel's own uploads:
“What should you use instead of subscribers for channel analytics? Well, there’s a lot of metrics that even advanced YouTubers easily get wrong, like AVD and CTR. I don’t blame people for looking at these, they’re freaking hard metrics to interpret correctly and there’s not really a good evidence-based source of truth for how to do so yet.”
“"tech" or "ai" was in 6 of better creating's bottom 10 uploads from the last 12 months. it was in only 1 of the top 10. so before a video goes out, check it against the channel's own flops. a best practice list cannot tell you what your viewer ignores. your history can.”
With both long-form and Shorts in the mix, Paddy Galloway draws a clear line:
“I would say biggest mistake is… Using short form to inform long form. They are two different beasts, just because something is viral on short form doesn’t mean that topic will convert. To get great at long form you need to study what is doing great in… long form!”
Use CreatorSide YouTube Scraper to export each competitor's complete video metadata as a CSV. Bring those records into the spreadsheet you review with your freelance editor. YouTube Scraper