Strategist answers · Fitness · under 50K
At 14K subs, I make fitness Shorts alone, but growth has stopped; how do I find unusually successful beginner workout videos without spending my only filming evening checking channels manually?
For 10K-20K Fitness channels; solo; Shorts-first; stalled.
84% of this answer is quoted word for word from 5 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
For a stalled fitness Shorts channel at 14K subscribers, these passages offer research settings and a measurement caveat:
“Outlier niche research settings: > Outlier Score: 2x+ > Views: 100K+ > Subscribers: max 25K (smaller channels only) > Publication date: Last month You can just play around with these settings to find interesting niches 👀”
“- What should you use instead of subscribers for channel analytics? Well, there’s a lot of metrics that even advanced YouTubers easily get wrong, like AVD and CTR. I don’t blame people for looking at these, they’re freaking hard metrics to interpret correctly and there’s not really a good evidence-based source of truth for how to do so yet.”
For the beginner workout audience, 1of10 addresses repeated success, while Daniel Faraday distinguishes the audience's starting point:
“But here's the key: outlier validation So don't just find 1 outlier on a topic Find 3+ videos on the same concept that all became outliers (recently) Because it worked for 3 channels, it'll probably work for you too”
“far more people want to *achieve* something than *optimise* something they've already achieved. think about fitness. millions of people want to lose their first 20 pounds. far fewer are interested in fixing their bench press technique. or finance. far more people want to make their first £10,000 than optimise the taxes on an investment portfolio. neither audience is necessarily better. but they're at completely different stages, and the size of those audiences can be very different.”
Leroy ter Braak and Daniel Faraday describe different research schedules; the constraint here is a solo creator's only filming evening:
“I spend at LEAST 120 minutes per week on idea research. It's the highest-ROI thing for YouTubers. Here's the exact process (steal it): First, I pick 10-20 channels adjacent to our niche. Mix of sizes: some bigger, some smaller, some at the same level.”
“You strap it back, you translate it, and you make sure you have your unique advantage tags in it, and then you run it through the template to see if the data behind it works. Set a timer for 20 minutes and do this every day, and do not break the chain.”
Beyond the workout clips appearing in a Shorts feed, Ed Lawrence offers an example from a neighbouring niche:
“so a few years ago everyone in the yoga Niche was making the same mistake so instead of copying what everyone else was doing wrong we researched adjacent niches like Fitness and mobility and found that short tip-based videos worked best meanwhile in yogaland everyone was just making half an hour lessons so we switched to this format and five videos in we generated millions of views”
For stalled growth, Leroy ter Braak emphasises signals and improvement; Ed Lawrence adds a caveat about making more videos:
“A - Assess Look at your channel and your competitors. Find the videos that outperformed everything else. Those are signals. Most creators see them and don't value them enough. B - Build Start making videos that align with those signals. But don't just copy. Make every video a few percentage points better than the last. Better hooks, better stories, better packaging.”
“Which makes sense on the surface — more videos, more views, more growth. But if the content isn't landing because you don't really understand what your viewer is struggling with, making more of it just means getting further from the answer faster.”
CreatorSide YouTube Scraper exports a channel's complete video metadata as a CSV. Put your reference channels into spreadsheets so you can compare potential outliers before your next filming evening. YouTube Scraper
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.