Strategist answers · Gaming · 500K to 2M
Our long gaming uploads keep shrinking at around 1.9M subs, and my eight-person team brings me conflicting advice about upload frequency and dead subscribers; how do I work out what's actually happening?
For 1.5M-2M Gaming channels; full team (6+); long-form only; declining.
86% of this answer is quoted word for word from 6 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
At 1.9M subs, the dead subscriber theory is common, but notification complaints and recommendation behaviour are worth separating first.
“I saw Tom (@Syndicate) tweet recently that he felt disheartened his views are dropping, and that viewers weren’t getting notified about new uploads. I think this is an important tweet because I see this a lot. From both sides, viewer and creator.”
“The viral moment comes when YouTube starts to show this video to a wider audience and it still performs really well. This tells you that the video appears to a lot of people, not only fans of Matt Rober, so they start to recommend it to more and more people who they feel will enjoy the content. This is often called the algorithm picking up a video. It keeps being recommended until it eventually begins to plateau and decline.”
Dabi and Ed Lawrence both point to returning viewers rather than raw subscriber totals.
“As attention becomes more scarce, divided amongst infinite options, people will perhaps as a habit default to only watching that which they already trust. One of the most useful insights from working with a few multi-million sub creators behind-the-scenes was simply the fact”
“So my goal as a YouTube isn't to get more views. It's to build a community of viewers who come back. The biggest problem is everyone right now is chasing views, especially in the finance niche. They wanna do side hustle and passive income videos because that's where the views are. And I'm like, that's where the views are. But when that trend goes, you won't be left with any viewers.”
On upload frequency, the strategists genuinely differ, which may explain the split advice inside an eight-person team.
“And two, if you hire people, you do as an employer have a responsibility to keep them compensated with inflation sal, you know, like so for us, we just were always publishing more and more out of that reflection. But we did get to a point this year at 20 years when I was like, I told my team, I go, do you need that sixth video? Do you need that fifth video?”
“Even when you don't know what to do, doing anything gives you vital feedback. View counts. Retention graphs. Comments. By accepting this feedback, you will win. Here's what you need to do. 1) Stop planning uploads and posting once a week. 2) Publish. Get feedback. Adjust. Publish again.”
“My favourite upload strategy - 1x long form per week - 3-5 shorts per week - Try a “big swing” video once/quarter Everyone is different but I enjoy this approach and have crushed with it.”
To settle the debate with evidence rather than opinion, Ed Lawrence and Daniel Faraday point back to what the long-form audience data says.
“so lesson number nine is to stop telling yourself that your videos are just as good or better than other channels growing faster than yours you might think they are but the audience is telling you otherwise”
“And the prompt is analyze my retention data and tell me the segments and mistakes that cause a long drop, gradual boredom, or a sudden drop so I can fix these for future videos.”
Ground your team's next diagnosis in The YouTube Algorithm: Explained. Dabi's guide explains ranking and recommendation mechanics through CTR, AVD and satisfaction signals, helping you replace myths with mechanics. Algorithm guide
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.