How do I explain that a rival's helpful moments belong in my gaming edits, when my growing channel has 14.2M subs and eight staff keep delivering long videos and Shorts that make every opponent look nasty?
For 14M-14.5M Gaming channels; full team (6+); long-form + Shorts; growing.
85% of this answer is quoted word for word from 7 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source.
For a growing gaming channel at 14.2M subs, the starting point is how strategists view likeability and negativity on screen.
“Stop being the villain in your content. The main-character (protagonist) must be likeable for the stakes to land. You do this by showcasing positive traits and relatability. Negative traits (aggression, selfishness) hurt retention.”
“I think sometimes it's quite easy to view YouTube as a whole in a negative light. It can at times feel like a toxic environment that is built on bringing other people down to fight your way to the top. However, MrBeast is a perfect example that by being a genuine, positive and likeable person, you can still rise to the very top of this platform.”
On the role of multiple characters, including antagonists, two strategists offer different angles:
“characters make stories more interesting because viewers can gravitate towards one a lot more than another. And when you double your characters, you double your chance of keeping your viewers interested.”
“YouTube storytelling starts in the concept/ideation, because the idea alone frontloads everything that can be done with a video. The best idea from this perspective has a mix of: - Likely character progression, ideally multiple likeable characters, sometimes antagonists”
Mario Joos and Vexian place more weight on conflict and antagonists than on pure likeability:
“On a serious note: I'd mainly look for what keeps the viewer. Don't obsess too much over spikes and dips unless you're doing tutorials, but telling a great story with enough conflict is probably where you're going to see the most amount of success”
“The video takes a dual protagonist approach ("averyismayo" and "d3rlord") , each one layered as a juxtaposition "naive but smart", they're both exploring the same world, a "peaceful" world with no answers and it's surrounded by suspense. 2 Main protagonists (plus this mysterious character with no face, as the antagonist) not only doubles but adds a complex web of interests.”
With eight staff cutting long videos and Shorts, these points speak to leadership and character across the whole channel:
“if there are comments that an employee makes early on it is up to you as the leader to kind of pull that person be like hey that thing you said don't say that and also if I say something that's like a joke that I shouldn't say people if they tell me I'm not like who are you I could do what I want right”
“Newer (especially younger) creators often focus way too much on chasing views first, rather than doing something fundamentally good/interesting as a baseline. Deficiency of character is especially prevalent.”
Join Coeditor's invite-only beta waitlist and try a style document that spells out how you portray opponents. Its readable cut decisions give you specific choices to review and overrule. Coeditor