Strategist answers · Video podcast · 500K to 2M
Our eight-person video podcast team wants to add solo deep dives at 1.9M subs, but interviews are still growing; could changing our long-form format stop my existing episodes getting recommended?
For 1.5M-2M Video podcast channels; full team (6+); long-form only; growing.
84% of this answer is quoted word for word from 7 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
At 1.9M subs, Mario Joos and Dabi both point to individual videos rather than the channel as a whole:
“Feel free to use the existing channel. It’s not going to hurt you. YouTube doesn’t really evaluate the channel as much as it evaluates the individual videos”
“Interestingly I actually did a massive informal study on this once when trying to build a views predictive model with several hundred K videos worth of metadata. So day 1 trajectory there was surprisingly super predictive of how the video would perform overall.”
Daniel Faraday and Mario Joos weigh single-format focus differently:
“Fragile content strategy: 1) Copying outlier topics and formats 2) Chasing what worked for your competitors 3) Doubling-down on a single format One policy change, one market shift - and your entire strategy collapses. The next level-up is a robust strategy.”
“Depends on your goals, but for growth, I'd always lead towards gradually shifting more towards that one format and finding new formats that could match that performance”
For the solo deep dives themselves, 1of10 and Daniel Faraday offer a framing:
“Nearly every winning video idea and title can be broken down into 2 things: PROVEN FORMAT + INTEREST TOPIC Viral formats are constantly changing, while interest topics are a lot more evergreen.”
“If the format itself is familiar, the topic needs to do more work. If the format is strange and unfamiliar, put something inside it the viewer already understands. The mistake is combining a format they've seen fifty times with a subject they've also seen fifty times.”
For an eight-person team, one long-running media operator describes launching new things:
“So, like a few years ago, I was like, I like entrepreneurship, we launched context, we paused it when COVID hit cuz I wanted the team just to streamline again. Sometimes you go wide, sometimes you go narrow, but I was like, okay, you could you have all these great people on your team and you could launch new things.”
Ed Lawrence and Leroy ter Braak add a final angle:
“So I shifted my attention towards the actual business and providing more value and helping the audience that I'd already built rather than obsessing over continually to increase the amount of attention I got.”
“Produce great videos that people want to see. YouTube WILL find your video and pull it in front of an amount of people you'd never imagine possible.”
Before committing the team to solo deep dives, read The YouTube Algorithm: Explained. Dabi's guide explains evaluation, ranking and recommendation through CTR, AVD and satisfaction signals so you can question format-change myths. Algorithm guide
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.