My video podcast is growing around 6.3M subs, but our four-person team wants to publish audience call-ins between interviews and Shorts; could one unpredictable episode make recommendations less reliable for the whole channel?
For 6M-6.5M Video podcast channels; small team (2-5); long-form + Shorts; growing.
84% of this answer is quoted word for word from 5 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source.
For a 6.3M video podcast weighing call-ins between guest interviews, the debate starts with audience overlap.
“Reality: Posting wildly different topics on one channel causes audience segmentation, which confuses YouTube's algorithm. ( Plus, most of the time, a video flops because the idea and packaging format weren't right for that particular audience.)”
“The rule of thumb I like to go by is 80% audience overlap. So what I mean by that is across everything on a channel um I I always want to as I always want to make sure that at least 80% of the audience would click on any combination of those videos.”
Mario Joos sees it differently, which is relevant for a team running long-form episodes alongside Shorts:
“Feel free to use the existing channel. It’s not going to hurt you. YouTube doesn’t really evaluate the channel as much as it evaluates the individual videos”
“I’ve got some good news for you, the short form content is not hurting your long form content at all. There’s no proof for this either. People might say that, but these algorithms are different and they serve different audiences.”
Leroy ter Braak leans towards the overlap view, with one caveat for personality-led channels:
“Upload topics that are closely related to each other. If you can’t find solid reasons for a viewer of video 1 to watch video 2 on your end screen, you are hurting your short term growth.”
“I wouldn’t personally revive a legacy channel if the content is wildly different from before, with a tiny exception being that if you are a true YouTube “star”, you could get away with it potentially. But that’s the top 0.01% where personality drives viewership vs the content”
Ed Lawrence and the 1of10 Podcast weigh serving regular viewers against doubling down differently, a useful tension for a growing four-person team:
“But at the same time, every video I make has a goal. It's often not get lots of new viewers. It often might be bring people back to the channel or it might be like, oh, let's try and get people to sign up the email. It's not necessarily about new. If you keep writing for the new, you can often start playing it too safe, and it gets a bit boring.”
“doubling down on what's working uh because again, if we want to reduce audience segmentation, you're going to be you're going to have a few concepts that are going to perform really well. And of course, we want to try new things, but we always want to be doubling down on what's working as well.”
Read Dabi's The YouTube Algorithm: Explained before judging the call-in idea by channel-wide penalty fears. It explains how videos are evaluated, ranked and recommended through CTR, AVD and satisfaction signals. Algorithm guide