Strategist answers · Spectacle / stunt · 500K to 2M
At around 1.8M subs, my stunt Shorts have stalled; how do I get usable rough cuts when automatic edits remove the nervous pause before each attempt and my freelancer has to rebuild it?
For 1.5M-2M Spectacle / stunt channels; solo + freelance editor; Shorts-first; stalled.
85% of this answer is quoted word for word from 5 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
For stunt Shorts stalled at around 1.8M subs, it helps to see how Paddy Galloway reads pauses and held soundbites in tense edits.
“It starts slow and then as the time ticks by the tension builds. The way this tension is extenuated in the edit is super smart. As the scene develops, the cuts get faster, the music builds and soundbites like these are left in to emphasize the time pressure.”
“in these opening 10 seconds there were 11 different sound changes the discord pinging almost forces you to stay engaged the explosion sound effects and music add variety and the awkward pauses emphasizes the humor it's very hard to feel bored with so much happening a lot of creators focus all their attention on the visual edits and not enough on the sound”
Mario Joos and George Blackman add a caveat about when held moments stop working.
“When I work with creators on their content, we often break down a scene and identify every single action that’s being taken, then judge whether each action is progressive or non-progressive towards the scene goal or the overall narrative goal. Having a few non-progressive moments is fine, but if your video stalls for around 30 seconds, you’re almost guaranteed to lose a lot of viewers.”
“It was basically just continuously hyping how interesting and exciting the content was about to get without actually delivering anything satisfying. Bit like watching Sherlock. And the viewer can feel this, by the way. It comes across like you're stalling and it makes it way too easy for them to click away.”
Ed Lawrence tested automatic editing directly, and his results on cut placement were mixed.
“It took 40 minutes of out-of-order footage, reordered it correctly, cut it up, and added basic text and graphics without making a mistake at a speed that is not possible for a human to do. I was a pro editor for five years, I am very fast at editing, but that would have taken me about an hour and it would have been a really boring, annoying job I would have hated.”
“Okay, cool. So we're just asked it to add them in sparingly when it believed it made sense to add a jump cut. And look, it kind of did it.”
For a solo creator relying on one freelance editor, Mario Joos and Dabi each frame the limits of generic automation.
“AI is an absolutely fantastic tool that could be used to speed up your creative processes, however, it is often used to replace the entire creative process.”
“The editing quality of it aims to achieve 95% of your finished edit, meaning that there are some HARD technical challenges solved that maybe like <3 people in the world would be able to solve (or even think about). It is not solvable by people with only YouTube experience, and also not solvable by people with only AI experience.”
Coeditor plans cuts against 90 storytelling rules and explains each decision so you can overrule it. Join the invite-only beta waitlist to try that approach with your next stunt. Coeditor
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.