Since my stunt channel reached 18K subs, views have slipped; how do I keep a long video tense when I've already revealed the whole challenge in the opening?
For 10K-20K Spectacle / stunt channels; solo; long-form only; declining.
84% of this answer is quoted word for word from 5 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source.
For a long-form stunt channel at 18K subs, Paddy Galloway pinpoints where tension usually leaks after an opening reveal:
“however after the intro is where a lot of youtubers encounter a problem the rest of their video just can't match the energy we can visualize a lot of youtube videos with this energy graph the video starts high with tension and energy but then drops off and only starts to peak again towards the end if you go through the island video it looks more like this every few minutes mr beast creates tension in the storyline with his challenges”
As a solo creator, the stunt premise alone may not carry the runtime; Dabi and Mario Joos focus on what surrounds it:
“The inverse is somewhat true. Even with somewhat average footage, you can boost a video up quite a bit just by including the right humor and audience rewards in the right places, and do characters/stakes etc. in a way that turns an otherwise average video into a very enjoyable one.”
“However, viewers don't always remember everything you tell them. And to make sure that we keep the impact of such suspense alive, we need to regularly remind the viewer of what's at stake so that we can keep that sense of fear. This tension will help to carry retention. In fact, tension or suspense are some of the best ways to keep people watching for longer.”
George Blackman names the worry behind an early reveal, and Paddy Galloway breaks down a stunt sequence:
“if the setup is the bit that promised something exciting, and the payoff, well, pays it off, then isn't the tension just withholding the information that the viewer actually cares about in a kind of frustrating way? Now, honestly, I get why it feels that way, but what I'm going to do now is show you the simple three-step formula I use to write tension that allows you to teach the viewer new information continuously without giving away that payoff until the end.”
“It starts slow and then as the time ticks by the tension builds. The way this tension is extenuated in the edit is super smart. As the scene develops, the cuts get faster, the music builds and soundbites like these are left in to emphasize the time pressure. Jimmy even manages to include some character development. frequently focusing on number 67 and 456. This intentionally creates subplots.”
Mario Joos adds a caveat about constant tension, and Daniel Faraday points to the person on screen:
“In videos where tension is present a lot, make sure to also have small relaxed moments. Emotional variations make it easier for viewers to stay engaged, as they won't feel stressed by the constant tension you're presenting to them.”
“The main-character (protagonist) must be likeable for the stakes to land. You do this by showcasing positive traits and relatability. Negative traits (aggression, selfishness) hurt retention.”
For a channel in decline posting long-form only, Dabi offers a note on timing:
“There are more recent long videos I’ve worked on and they just get 1 million (engaged) views over a few months. Sometimes videos are like stocks, in that in the long term, the market is a weighing machine rather than a voting machine.”
Dabi's YouTube Storytelling: Far Beyond Retention covers the mid-video death and weak payoffs. Work through its structure lessons before scripting your next stunt. Storytelling course