Strategist answers · Tech reviews · 500K to 2M
Why do my tech reviews and quick clips get launch traffic without growing my channel past 1.7M subs, even with seven of us producing videos and hardly anyone coming back for the next review?
For 1.5M-2M Tech reviews channels; full team (6+); long-form + Shorts; stalled.
88% of this answer is quoted word for word from 7 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
For a tech review channel stalled near 1.7M subs, launch traffic and returning viewers behave very differently:
“It only tells you something useful in the first 24-48 hours IF you have a returning viewer base. After that, it's noise. Once a video starts performing, the algorithm surfaces it to people outside your core”
“An embedded creator wins on recurring audience trust. Someone who's been subscribed for over 2 years will click on any video because they already trust the creator. They won't be clicking because of the packaging is irresistible to a cold viewer. And so, you need to do them in two very different ways. An emerging creator wins in suggested feeds. That's cold traffic with a no prior viewer relationship. And because of this, the video on its own has to earn the click.”
1of10 and Dabi disagree on how much the subscriber number itself should matter:
“Subscribers ≠ audience All a subscriber really is, is someone who clicked a button one time. It doesn't mean they'll watch your next video. So even though there's a lot of ego and prestige that comes with a big subscriber count”
“Subscribers are the emotional stock of a YouTube channel as a system. Even if we know subscribers aren’t views per se, it’s a number we can’t help but want to keep push up and up. A failure of a video may be painful. But it’s a lot less painful if your channel is emotionally perceived a weighing machine rather than a betting machine. After all, a 10/10 video (flop) isn’t so bad when you have a few million subscribers. Your subscribers may even trickle upwards.”
Running long-form and Shorts side by side adds another wrinkle, according to Mario Joos:
“At first glance, this sounds great. People are gaining rather than losing views, right? But those views, and that time spent, have to come from somewhere. While YouTube isn’t a zero-sum game, we do believe this signal indicates that the browse UI changes are having an impact somewhere else. We believe that these UI changes are slowly affecting long-form performance for creators, even if the drops aren’t very noticeable over a shorter period of time.”
With seven people producing videos, the question of volume versus return viewing comes up from several angles:
“Patrick Bet-David’s smaller YouTube channel, PBD Podcast, gets almost 5× more typical views per video. • Valuetainment: 7.16M subscribers, 300 long videos in 4 months, about 2.5/day, 76K typical views • PBD Podcast: 2.98M subscribers, 51 videos in 12 months, 360K typical”
“I told my team, I go, do you need that sixth video? Do you need that fifth video? Do you need that seventh video? So we are now at that point where we are going to be probably launching new things and shifting some of the resources to those new things.”
“Simple rationale: if the niche is small, putting more time in has diminishing marginal returns. There’s not an infinite amount of viewers so I’d rather hit that small group regularly than chase a higher % of TAM when the TAM is small.”
Give your next launch review a story beyond the purchase verdict. YouTube Storytelling: Far Beyond Retention covers structuring, scripting and editing for retention and satisfaction across 38 lessons. Storytelling course
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.