Strategist answers · Tech reviews · 500K to 2M
At around 1.9M subs, my tech review views are falling because our eight-person team writes detailed long videos but edits everything like quick clips; how do I get everyone following the same story?
For 1.5M-2M Tech reviews channels; full team (6+); long-form + Shorts; declining.
84% of this answer is quoted word for word from 7 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
For an eight-person tech review team, the starting point is what a script is actually for.
“It's also why in Hollywood, and they make 99% of films, they don't give actors a list of bullet points to just riff and tell the entire story from, instead they write a script to ensure that viewers are always 100% engaged and invested, because if they're not, they get a massive flaw.”
“Scripts aren't just words on a page, they're the backbone of your content, the blueprint of your brand, and the bridge between you and your audience.”
On the editing side, Mario Joos and Dabi look at how visuals land against what is being said.
“Next thing, what I do notice with the visualization is that the visuals don't always match with what you're saying, or what I think you're saying. And then even whenever you're talking about the price, which I know you're talking about the price, you show the visual, but we don't zoom in on the actual pricing. So we are just showing wide screenshots, no zoom-ins or anything like that”
“YouTubers, on the other hand, have a much stronger sense of “this is fascinating if presented this way rather than that way”. For the best, even very small details about the visuals or audio or plot are all sensed. A great YouTuber can tell how an audience reacts to a specific part of a video; it’s really a skill to develop that sense.”
On the overall shape of a long review, George Blackman and Paddy Galloway offer different models.
“In pretty much any movie ever, the biggest moment of drama happens at the end of act three, right? Yes, there might be a couple of biggish moments in acts one and two, but ultimately, the people die, fall in love, explode, take revenge, save the world, or rescue the cat right at the very end. The whole story exists to serve that final moment, and honestly, you see the same approach with entertainment content on YouTube as well.”
“the penny series videos are basically a pendulum swinging between retention optimized moments and deeper connections to his personality a lot of youtubers are neglecting this side of the equation something ryan has capitalized on”
With Shorts and long reviews running side by side, Mario Joos questions any conflict between formats, while Daniel Faraday warns about volume.
“I'd love to see the data because there's no reason, from our current understanding about how the algorithms work, that would indicate mediums cannot live hand-in-hand”
“Posting more kept the channel busy. It didn’t make each video get more views. If views per video are falling, doubling the posting rate probably won’t fix the problem.”
For a channel in decline, Ed Lawrence and Leroy ter Braak weigh quick views against longer term value.
“Then I would focus far more on building trust than chasing virality. Because attention gets you noticed and the views are gonna feel really good, but leaning into it too heavily, it won't save you when that fall off does happen. So focus on trust because that's gonna pay you for decades.”
“There is a balance you need to find. Not all views are created equal. Meaning that you should most probably sacrifice some views for a longer term gain.”
Give your writers and editors a shared system through YouTube Storytelling: Far Beyond Retention. Its 38 lessons cover structure, scripting and editing, including copying pacing without understanding the story. Storytelling course
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.