Strategist answers · Travel · 10M+
At 10.6M subs, my travel views are falling because people leave between the challenge setup and final reveal; how do I stop our documentary team stitching Shorts-friendly highlights into a weak middle?
For 10.5M-11M Travel channels; full team (6+); long-form + Shorts; declining.
83% of this answer is quoted word for word from 7 YouTube strategists. Each quote links to its source. Last updated .
For a travel channel at 10.6M subs, the first question is what the drop between setup and reveal actually means.
“We refer to these moments as segmentation loss, and they could happen because people are done with the video, they don't like it anymore, or sometimes even just because they were satisfied”
“YouTubers, on the other hand, have a much stronger sense of “this is fascinating if presented this way rather than that way”. For the best, even very small details about the visuals or audio or plot are all sensed. A great YouTuber can tell how an audience reacts to a specific part of a video; it’s really a skill to develop that sense.”
Paddy Galloway and Daniel Faraday look at the setup and the middle of the story:
“He mentions that 30 minutes inside the quiet room supposedly drives you insane, and then goes on to say he believes that's a myth. He instantly gives the video a why. This is a very optimized start, but then he lets his personality show in his editing.”
“search “building a cabin”: a thumbnail of the finished cabin answers the question. a thumbnail of the cabin half built asks one: will this actually work? if the video shows the build, show the middle. the viewer clicks to see how it ends.”
For a declining channel running long-form and Shorts, 1of10 frames why the long episode's session matters:
“YouTube's #1 goal is keeping people on the platform So if your video is the reason the viewer doesn't leave the platform, that means YouTube will push your video to more people”
“These are the signals that actually determine reach, and almost none of them show up in your dashboard: - Likes-to-views ratio - Comments per 1K views - Shares per view - Binge rate - Subs-to-views ratio”
Ed Lawrence, Daniel Faraday and Vexian weigh it differently, warning a full team against chasing attention at the expense of trust and distinctiveness:
“it won't save you when that fall off does happen. So focus on trust because that's gonna pay you for decades. So I'd be thinking about always trying to make the most genuinely useful content, not just trying to trick people to click or trick them to watch for longer.”
“REACH is what you get by optimizing for attention. Views, clicks, impressions. When you're chasing reach, you're making content that travels, not content that matters. INFLUENCE is what remains when the views stop coming.”
“came on the scene, maxd impact now is make the same stuff everyone else has and is eroding the moat he made and losing viewer equity.”
Build the middle around story structure with Dabi's YouTube Storytelling: Far Beyond Retention. The course addresses copying pacing without story and the mid-video death. Storytelling course
Every quote is copied word for word, credited to the person who said it and linked to the original post or video. Spotted a misquote or a missing credit? Tell us and we'll fix it.